The Farmyard Cock and the Weathercock
by Hans Christian Andersen · from Collected Fairy Tales
Adapted Version
Do you know two roosters? One was loud. He stood on a dirt pile. The other was quiet. He sat on a roof.
A green plant grew on the dirt pile. It saw The Loud Rooster. "You are so strong!" said the plant. "The quiet rooster does nothing."
One night, a big storm came. The wind blew hard. The rain fell fast. The Hens and The Chicks hid. The Loud Rooster hid too. The Quiet Rooster stayed still.
The Quiet Rooster did not like other birds. They flew and chirped. He thought they were silly. He thought their stories were boring. "This world is not good," he thought.
The storm went away. The Loud Rooster crowed loudly. "Cock-a-doodle-doo!" he called. He thought his crow was the best.
The Loud Rooster saw the green plant. "Garden plant!" he said. He pecked the plant. He ate it all up. The green plant was gone.
The Hens and The Chicks came close. They liked The Loud Rooster. He crowed for them. He said they would grow big.
"I can lay a magic egg!" he said. "It is a very special egg!" The Hens looked with wide eyes. The Chicks chirped loudly.
The Hens and Chicks looked with wide eyes. They thought he was very strong. They were proud of their Loud Rooster.
The Quiet Rooster heard the noise. He did not move at all. "So silly!" he thought to himself.
He thought he could do something special. But he did not want to. "I do not like this world," he thought. "I don't like this!"
Then The Quiet Rooster fell down. He fell from the roof. No one was hurt. The Hens were surprised.
The Loud Rooster kept crowing. He kept doing things. The Quiet Rooster stayed on the ground. It is good to do things. It is not good to think bad thoughts.
Original Story
There were two cocks– one on the dung-hill, the other on the roof. They were both arrogant, but which of the two rendered most service? Tell us your opinion– we'll keep to ours just the same though. The poultry yard was divided by some planks from another yard in which there was a dung-hill, and on the dung-hill lay and grew a large cucumber which was conscious of being a hot-bed plant. "One is born to that," said the cucumber to itself. "Not all can be born cucumbers; there must be other things, too. The hens, the ducks, and all the animals in the next yard are creatures too. Now I have a great opinion of the yard cock on the plank; he is certainly of much more importance than the weather-cock who is placed so high and can't even creak, much less crow. The latter has neither hens nor chicks, and only thinks of himself and perspires verdigris. No, the yard cock is really a cock! His step is a dance! His crowing is music, and wherever he goes one knows what a trumpeter is like! If he would only come in here! Even if he ate me up stump, stalk, and all, and I had to dissolve in his body, it would be a happy death," said the cucumber. In the night there was a terrible storm. The hens, chicks, and even the cock sought shelter; the wind tore down the planks between the two yards with a crash; the tiles came tumbling down, but the weather-cock sat firm. He did not even turn round, for he could not; and yet he was young and freshly cast, but prudent and sedate. He had been born old, and did not at all resemble the birds flying in the air– the sparrows, and the swallows; no, he despised them, these mean little piping birds, these common whistlers. He admitted that the pigeons, large and white and shining like mother-of-pearl, looked like a kind of weather- cock; but they were fat and stupid, and all their thoughts and endeavours were directed to filling themselves with food, and besides, they were tiresome things to converse with. The birds of passage had also paid the weather-cock a visit and told him of foreign countries, of airy caravans and robber stories that made one's hair stand on end. All this was new and interesting; that is, for the first time, but afterwards, as the weather-cock found out, they repeated themselves and always told the same stories, and that's very tedious, and there was no one with whom one could associate, for one and all were stale and small- minded. "The world is no good!" he said. "Everything in it is so stupid." The weather-cock was puffed up, and that quality would have made him interesting in the eyes of the cucumber if it had known it, but it had eyes only for the yard cock, who was now in the yard with it. The wind had blown the planks, but the storm was over. "What do you think of that crowing?" said the yard cock to the hens and chickens. "It was a little rough– it wanted elegance." And the hens and chickens came up on the dung-hill, and the cock strutted about like a lord. "Garden plant!" he said to the cucumber, and in that one word his deep learning showed itself, and it forgot that he was pecking at her and eating it up. "A happy death!" The hens and the chickens came, for where one runs the others run too; they clucked, and chirped, and looked at the cock, and were proud that he was of their kind. "Cock-a-doodle-doo!" he crowed, "the chickens will grow up into great hens at once, if I cry it out in the poultry-yard of the world!" And hens and chicks clucked and chirped! And the cock announced a great piece of news. "A cock can lay an egg! And do you know what's in that egg? A basilisk. No one can stand the sight of such a thing; people know that, and now you know it too– you know what is in me, and what a champion of all cocks I am!" With that the yard cock flapped his wings, made his comb swell up, and crowed again; and they all shuddered, the hens and the little chicks– but they were very proud that one of their number was such a champion of all cocks. They clucked and chirped till the weather-cock heard; he heard it; but he did not stir. "Everything is very stupid," the weather-cock said to himself. "The yard cock lays no eggs, and I am too lazy to do so; if I liked, I could lay a wind-egg. But the world is not worth even a wind-egg. Everything is so stupid! I don't want to sit here any longer." With that the weather-cock broke off; but he did not kill the yard cock, although the hens said that had been his intention. And what is the moral? "Better to crow than to be puffed up and break off!
Story DNA
Moral
It is better to be useful and active, even if flawed, than to be passively arrogant and ultimately useless.
Plot Summary
Two arrogant cocks, one a boisterous yard cock and the other a passive weathercock, are introduced. A cucumber admires the yard cock, while the weathercock disdains all other creatures. After a storm, the yard cock boasts to his admiring flock, even claiming he can lay a basilisk egg, while the weathercock dismisses everything as 'stupid.' Ultimately, the weathercock breaks off his perch, demonstrating his uselessness, while the yard cock continues his active, albeit arrogant, existence, leading to the moral that it's better to be active than passively puffed up.
Themes
Emotional Arc
arrogance to ironic downfall
Writing Style
Narrative Elements
Cultural Context
Hans Christian Andersen's tales often subtly critiqued societal norms or human foibles through animal allegories, reflecting 19th-century European values and social structures.
Plot Beats (13)
- Introduction of two arrogant cocks: a yard cock on a dung-hill and a weathercock on a roof, with an open question about their service.
- A cucumber on the dung-hill expresses admiration for the yard cock and dismisses the weathercock as useless.
- A terrible storm rages, forcing the yard animals to shelter, tearing down planks and tiles, but the weathercock remains fixed.
- The weathercock, born 'old' and prudent, despises flying birds and finds the stories of migratory birds tedious and repetitive, concluding 'The world is no good! Everything in it is so stupid.'
- The storm passes, and the yard cock, now in the cucumber's yard, crows, belittling his own performance for elegance.
- The yard cock addresses the cucumber as 'Garden plant!' and pecks it, consuming it, which the cucumber perceives as a 'happy death'.
- The hens and chicks gather around the yard cock, proud of him, as he crows about their future growth.
- The yard cock boasts that he can lay an egg containing a basilisk, impressing his flock with his supposed power.
- The hens and chicks shudder but are proud of the yard cock's 'champion' status.
- The weathercock hears the commotion but doesn't stir, reiterating his belief that 'Everything is very stupid.'
- The weathercock muses he could lay a 'wind-egg' but deems the world not worth it, concluding 'Everything is so stupid! I don't want to sit here any longer.'
- The weathercock breaks off his perch, not killing the yard cock, despite the hens' belief it was his intention.
- The story concludes with the moral: 'Better to crow than to be puffed up and break off!'
Characters
Yard Cock
Large, colorful plumage, strong legs
Arrogant, boastful
Weathercock
Made of metal, possibly with verdigris
Puffed up, disdainful, lazy
Cucumber
Large, green, growing on a dung-hill
Admiring, self-sacrificing
Hens
Typical hen appearance
Easily impressed, followers
Chicks
Small, fluffy, yellow
Easily impressed, followers
Locations
Poultry Yard
A fenced-in area with hens and chicks.
Mood: Lively, competitive
The yard cock struts and crows, impressing the hens and chicks with his supposed abilities.
Dung-hill
A composted pile of manure in a separate yard, where a cucumber grows.
Mood: Fertile, somewhat isolated
The cucumber expresses its admiration for the yard cock.
Rooftop
High above the farmyard, where the weathercock is perched.
Mood: Isolated, superior, unchanging
The weathercock observes the farmyard and judges everything as stupid, ultimately breaking off from its perch.