What the Whole Family Said
by Hans Christian Andersen · from Collected Fairy Tales
Adapted Version
It was Marie's birthday! She was very happy. She wore her pretty dress. She got many nice gifts. Marie loved her new doll.
"It is nice to be alive," Marie said. Grandpa smiled at her. "Life is the most wonderful story of all!" he said.
Marie's brothers played games. They liked to ride bikes. They liked to skate fast. They thought life was fun. They had many friends.
The cousins were big boys. They wanted to grow up. They wanted to see new places. Life was fun for them. They had big plans.
Mom and Dad smiled. Life can be tricky, they knew. But life is a good trip. It is always good. They loved their children.
Grandpa lived upstairs. His room was warm and cozy. He had many pretty things. Grandpa was old and very kind. He told good stories.
A fire burned in his room. It was warm and bright. Grandpa liked to watch it. The fire made him happy. He felt very calm.
Grandpa had a special book. It told many good stories. It helped people be good. He called it the best book. It was very old.
"This book helps me," Grandpa said. "It makes me feel safe. It is like a warm hug from God. It makes me happy. It gives comfort."
"Keep good thoughts in your heart," he said. "Then you will always feel safe. You will never be lost. God is with you."
Grandpa was sad at times. His eyes cried then. But now he is happy. God helps him each day. Life is good and bright.
"Life is a good story," Grandpa said. "God gives it to us. It is always good. It lasts always. We are lucky."
"Yes, life is good!" Marie said. She felt very happy. It was a good day.
All smiled. They all knew. Life is the most wonderful story of all! Grandpa knew this best of all. They felt much joy.
Original Story
What the whole family said
A fairy tale by Hans Christian Andersen
What did the whole family say? Well listen first to what little Marie said.
It was little Marie's birthday, the most wonderful of all days, she imagined. All her little boy friends and girl friends came to play with her, and she wore her prettiest dress, the one Grandmother, who was now with God, had sewn for her before she went up into the bright, beautiful heaven. The table in little Marie's room was loaded with presents; there was the prettiest little kitchen, with everything that belongs to a kitchen, and a doll that could close its eyes and say "Ouch!" when you pinched its stomach; yes, and there was also a picture book, with the most wonderful stories, to be read when one could read! But to have many birthdays was more wonderful than all the stories in the book.
"Yes, it's wonderful to be alive," said little Marie. And her godfather added that it was the most beautiful of all fairy tales.
In the next room were both her brothers; they were big boys, one of them nine years old, the other eleven. They thought it was wonderful to be alive, too; that is, to live in their own way, not to be a baby like Marie, but to be real smart schoolboys, to get A's on their report cards, to have friendly fights with their comrades, to go skating in the winter and bicycling in the summer, to read about the days of knighthood, with its castles, its drawbridges, and its dungeons, and to hear about new discoveries in Central Africa. On the latter subject, however, one of the boys felt very sad in that he feared everything might be discovered before he grew up, and then there would be no adventure left for him. But Godfather said, "Life itself is the most wonderful adventure, and you have a part in it yourself."
These children lived on the first floor of the house; in the flat above them lived another branch of the family, also with children, but these all had long since been shaken from their mother's apron strings, so big were they; one son was seventeen, and another twenty, but the third one was very old, said little Marie; he was twenty-five, and engaged to be married. They were all very well off, had nice parents, good clothes, and were well educated, and they knew what they wanted. "Look forward," they said. "Away with all the old fences! Let's have an open view into the wide world! That's the greatest thing we know of! Godfather is right - life is the most wonderful fairy tale!"
Father and Mother, both older people - naturally, they would have to be older than the children - said, with smiling lips and smiling eyes and hearts, "How young these young people are! Things usually don't happen in this world just as they expect them to, yet life goes on. Life is a strange and wonderful adventure."
On the next floor - a little closer to heaven, as we say when people live in an attic - lived Godfather. He was old, and yet so young in mind, always in a good humor, and he certainly could tell stories, many and long ones. He had traveled the world over, and his room was filled with pretty tokens from every country. Pictures were hung from ceiling to floor, and some of the windowpanes were of red or yellow glass; if one looked through them, the whole world lay in sunshine, however gray the weather might be outside. Green plants grew in a large glass case, and in an enclosure therein swam goldfish; they looked at one as if they knew many things they didn't care to talk about. There was always a sweet fragrance of flowers, even in the wintertime. And then a great fire blazed in the fireplace; it was such a pleasure to sit and look into it and hear how it crackled and spat.
"It refreshes old memories to me, " said Godfather. And to little Marie there seemed to appear many pictures in the fire.
But in the big bookcase close by stood real books; one of these Godfather often read, and this he called the Book of Books; it was the Bible. In it was pictured the history of the world and the history of all mankind, of the creation, the flood, the kings, and the King of Kings.
"All that has happened and all that will happen is written in this book," said Godfather; "so infinitely much in one single book! Just think of it! Yes, everything that a human being has to pray for is entered there, and said in a few words in the prayer 'Our Father'! It is the drop of mercy! It is the pearl of comfort from God. It is laid as a gift on the baby's cradle, laid on the child's heart. Little child, keep it safely; don't ever lose it, however big you may grow, and you will never be left alone on life's changeful way; it will shine within you and you will never be lost!"
Godfather's eyes radiated joy. Once, in his youth, they had wept, "and this was also good," he said. "That was a time of trial, when everything looked dark and gray. Now I have sunshine within me and around me. The older one grows, the clearer one sees, in both prosperity and misfortune, that our Lord always is with us and that life is the most beautiful of all fairy tales, and this He alone can give us - and so it will be into eternity."
"Yes, it is wonderful to be alive!" said little Marie.
So said also the small and the big boys, as well as Father and Mother and the whole family - but first of all, Godfather, who had had so much experience and was the oldest of them all. He knew all stories, all the fairy tales. And it was right from the bottom of his heart that he said, "Life is the most wonderful fairy tale of all!"
- * * * *
Story DNA
Moral
Life, with all its experiences and challenges, is the most wonderful fairy tale, especially when viewed through the lens of faith and gratitude.
Plot Summary
On her birthday, little Marie expresses her joy in being alive, prompting her family members, from her adventurous brothers and ambitious cousins to her experienced parents, to share their own perspectives on life's wonders. The wise Godfather, the oldest, reveals that true wonder comes from faith and the comfort found in his 'Book of Books,' the Bible, which teaches that life, despite its trials, is the most beautiful fairy tale. Ultimately, the entire family, influenced by Godfather's profound wisdom, agrees that 'Life is the most wonderful fairy tale of all!'
Themes
Emotional Arc
innocence to wisdom
Writing Style
Narrative Elements
Cultural Context
Reflects the societal structure and religious sentiment prevalent in 19th-century Denmark, where Christian faith was a cornerstone of life and family.
Plot Beats (14)
- Little Marie celebrates her birthday, enjoying her gifts and the simple wonder of being alive.
- Marie's godfather states that 'it's wonderful to be alive' and 'the most beautiful of all fairy tales.'
- Marie's two older brothers express their joy in life through their school activities, sports, and dreams of adventure.
- The older cousins, young adults, articulate their excitement for the future, progress, and an 'open view into the wide world.'
- The parents, with their life experience, smile at the youth's optimism but affirm life's strange and wonderful adventure despite its unpredictability.
- Godfather, living on the top floor, is introduced as an old but young-minded, well-traveled man with a cozy, memory-filled room.
- Godfather reflects on the fire's ability to refresh old memories and the joy it brings.
- Godfather points to his 'Book of Books,' the Bible, as containing the history of the world and all human wisdom.
- He explains that the Bible, and specifically the 'Our Father' prayer, offers infinite comfort and guidance, a 'pearl of comfort from God.'
- Godfather advises keeping this spiritual gift safe from childhood, ensuring one is never lost in life.
- He shares that his eyes once wept, but now radiate joy, having learned through trial that God is always with us.
- Godfather concludes that the older one grows, the clearer one sees that life is the most beautiful fairy tale, given by God, and lasting into eternity.
- Little Marie reiterates, 'Yes, it is wonderful to be alive!'
- The story concludes with the affirmation that the whole family, led by the experienced Godfather, agrees: 'Life is the most wonderful fairy tale of all!'
Characters
Marie
Pretty, wears her prettiest dress.
Attire: A pretty dress sewn by her Grandmother, likely a simple but well-made dress appropriate for a special occasion in a 19th-century Danish setting.
Innocent, joyful, appreciative.
Godfather
Old but young in mind, eyes radiate joy.
Attire: Comfortable, well-worn clothes, perhaps a smoking jacket or cardigan, reflecting his scholarly and traveled nature.
Wise, jovial, optimistic.
Brothers (9 and 11)
Energetic, typical schoolboys.
Attire: Practical school clothes, such as sturdy trousers, shirts, and jackets appropriate for mid-19th century Denmark.
Curious, adventurous, competitive.
Older Cousins (17, 20, 25)
Well-dressed, educated.
Attire: Stylish clothing reflecting their social status and education, such as tailored suits or jackets, crisp shirts, and polished shoes.
Ambitious, forward-thinking, worldly.
Father
Older than the children, smiling eyes.
Attire: Respectable middle-class attire, such as a suit or jacket, vest, and tie.
Content, observant, loving.
Mother
Older than the children, smiling lips and eyes.
Attire: A modest but elegant dress appropriate for a middle-class woman in 19th-century Denmark, possibly with a shawl or bonnet.
Warm, nurturing, wise.
Locations
Little Marie's Room
A room filled with birthday presents, including a little kitchen, a doll, and a picture book. A table is loaded with gifts.
Mood: joyful, celebratory, innocent
Marie's birthday celebration; she declares it is wonderful to be alive.
Godfather's Attic Room
A room filled with tokens from around the world, pictures from ceiling to floor, red and yellow windowpanes, green plants in a glass case, and goldfish in an enclosure. A large fire blazes in the fireplace.
Mood: warm, nostalgic, wise, comforting
Godfather shares his wisdom about life and the importance of faith.