Frau Trude
by Brothers Grimm

The Girl Who Did Not Listen
Once there is a little girl. Her name is Lily. She does not like to listen. Mama says, "Eat your soup." Lily says no. Papa says, "Come inside." Lily does not come.
Near the town there is a house. It has dark windows. The roof is old and crooked. Weeds grow by the door. No one goes near it. Lily wants to see it. "I want to go there," she says.
"No," says Mama. "Do not go there." Papa shakes his head. "It is not safe," he says. They look at Lily with big eyes. "Please, Lily. Stay home."
But Lily does not listen. She walks to the old house. The path is dark. The trees are tall.
The door opens. An old woman stands there. She looks at Lily. "Why so afraid?" asks Old Frau Trude. Lily's hands shake. Her heart beats fast.
"I saw a big black cat," says Lily. "It sat on your steps."
"I saw a green bird," says Lily. "It sat on your roof."
"I saw a red fox," says Lily. "It ran by your door."
Old Frau Trude laughs. "That is just my cat," she says. "Just a bird." "Just a fox."
"But," says Lily. Her voice is small. "I looked in the window. I saw your face. You had glowing eyes. And a scary face."
Old Frau Trude smiles a slow smile. "Yes," she says. "You saw the real me. I am a witch."
Then Old Frau Trude waves her hand. Lily cannot move. She is frozen like a statue. She cannot talk. She cannot run. She is all alone.
But Mama and Papa look for Lily. They walk and walk. They call her name. "Lily! Lily!" They find the old house. "Give us back our girl!" says Papa. Mama holds up a bright light. The spell breaks. Lily can move again! She runs to Mama and Papa. She holds them tight. "I am sorry," says Lily. "I did not listen." "I will listen now." Mama holds one hand. Papa holds the other. They walk home.
And from that day, Lily always listens.
Original Story
Frau Trude A fairy tale by the Brothers Grimm There was once a little girl who was obstinate and inquisitive, and when her parents told her to do anything, she did not obey them, so how could she fare well? One day she said to her parents, "I have heard so much of Frau Trude, I will go to her some day. People say that everything about her does look so strange, and that there are such odd things in her house, that I have become quite curious!" Her parents absolutely forbade her, and said, "Frau Trude is a bad woman, who does wicked things, and if thou goest to her; thou art no longer our child." But the maiden did not let herself be turned aside by her parent's prohibition, and still went to Frau Trude. And when she got to her, Frau Trude said, "Why art thou so pale?" - "Ah," she replied, and her whole body trembled, "I have been so terrified at what I have seen." - "What hast thou seen?" - "I saw a black man on your steps." - "That was a collier." - "Then I saw a green man." - "That was a huntsman." - "After that I saw a blood-red man." - "That was a butcher." - "Ah, Frau Trude, I was terrified; I looked through the window and saw not you, but, as I verily believe, the devil himself with a head of fire." - "Oho!" said she, "then thou hast seen the witch in her proper costume. I have been waiting for thee, and wanting thee a long time already; thou shalt give me some light." Then she changed the girl into a block of wood, and threw it into the fire. And when it was in full blaze she sat down close to it, and warmed herself by it, and said, "That shines bright for once in a way." * * * * *
Moral of the Story
Disobedience and unchecked curiosity can lead to terrible consequences.
Characters
Girl ★ protagonist
Pale complexion
Attire: Simple peasant dress, apron
Obstinate, inquisitive
Frau Trude ⚔ antagonist
Implied to have a frightening appearance, able to transform
Attire: Witch's costume, implied to be dark and imposing
Wicked, deceptive
Parents ◆ supporting
Not described
Attire: Typical peasant clothing
Protective, authoritative
Locations

The Parents' Home
A place of rules and obedience, though not described visually.
Mood: Restrictive, safe, but ultimately ineffective
The girl disobeys her parents' direct order.

Frau Trude's House - Exterior
The steps leading up to the house, where figures appear.
Mood: Terrifying, surreal, ominous
The girl encounters a series of increasingly frightening figures.

Frau Trude's House - Interior
Visible through the window, a room where the devil with a head of fire is seen.
Mood: Horrific, magical, dangerous
The girl sees the witch's true form and is lured inside.

The Fireplace
A large fireplace where Frau Trude burns the girl.
Mood: Violent, final, triumphant for the witch
The girl's transformation and death.
Story DNA
Moral
Disobedience and unchecked curiosity can lead to terrible consequences.
Plot Summary
A disobedient and overly curious girl, despite her parents' strict warnings, insists on visiting the mysterious Frau Trude. Upon arriving at Frau Trude's house, the girl is terrified by strange sights, culminating in her seeing Frau Trude as a fiery devil. Frau Trude, revealing herself as a witch, transforms the girl into a block of wood and burns her in the fireplace, warming herself by the blaze.
Themes
Emotional Arc
curiosity to terror
Writing Style
Narrative Elements
Cultural Context
Grimm's fairy tales often reflect a patriarchal society where disobedience, especially from young girls, is met with severe punishment. The figure of the witch is a common antagonist in German folklore.
Plot Beats (13)
- A little girl is characterized as obstinate and inquisitive, often disobeying her parents.
- The girl expresses a strong desire to visit Frau Trude, known for her strangeness and odd house.
- Her parents strictly forbid her from going, warning that Frau Trude is wicked and she would no longer be their child.
- Ignoring her parents, the girl goes to Frau Trude's house.
- Upon arrival, Frau Trude asks why the girl is so pale.
- The trembling girl recounts seeing a black man, a green man, and a blood-red man on the steps.
- Frau Trude dismisses these sightings as a collier, a huntsman, and a butcher, respectively.
- The girl then confesses to seeing Frau Trude through the window, appearing as the devil with a head of fire.
- Frau Trude confirms the girl saw her in her true witch form.
- Frau Trude states she has been waiting for the girl to provide light.
- Frau Trude transforms the girl into a block of wood.
- Frau Trude throws the wooden block into the fire.
- Frau Trude sits by the fire, warming herself and commenting on the bright light it provides.





