The Four Skilful Brothers
by Brothers Grimm · from Household Tales
Original Story
The four skilful brothers
A fairy tale by the Brothers Grimm
There was once a poor man who had four sons, and when they were grown up, he said to them, "My dear children, you must now go out into the world, for I have nothing to give you, so set out, and go to some distance and learn a trade, and see how you can make your way." So the four brothers took their sticks, bade their father farewell, and went through the town-gate together. When they had travelled about for some time, they came to a cross-way which branched off in four different directions. Then said the eldest, "Here we must separate, but on this day four years, we will meet each other again at this spot, and in the meantime we will seek our fortunes."
Then each of them went his way, and the eldest met a man who asked him where he was going, and what he was intending to do? "I want to learn a trade," he replied. Then the other said, "Come with me, and be a thief." - "No," he answered, "that is no longer regarded as a reputable trade, and the end of it is that one has to swing on the gallows." - "Oh," said the man, "you need not be afraid of the gallows; I will only teach you to get such things as no other man could ever lay hold of, and no one will ever detect you." So he allowed himself to be talked into it, and while with the man became an accomplished thief, and so dexterous that nothing was safe from him, if he once desired to have it. The second brother met a man who put the same question to him what he wanted to learn in the world. "I don't know yet," he replied. "Then come with me, and be an astronomer; there is nothing better than that, for nothing is hid from you." He liked the idea, and became such a skillful astronomer that when he had learnt everything, and was about to travel onwards, his master gave him a telescope and said to him, "With that you canst thou see whatsoever takes place either on earth or in heaven, and nothing can remain concealed from thee." A huntsman took the third brother into training, and gave him such excellent instruction in everything which related to huntsmanship, that he became an experienced hunter. When he went away, his master gave him a gun and said, "It will never fail you; whatsoever you aim at, you are certain to hit." The youngest brother also met a man who spoke to him, and inquired what his intentions were. "Would you not like to be a tailor?" said he. "Not that I know of," said the youth; "sitting doubled up from morning till night, driving the needle and the goose backwards and forwards, is not to my taste." - "Oh, but you are speaking in ignorance," answered the man; "with me you would learn a very different kind of tailoring, which is respectable and proper, and for the most part very honorable." So he let himself be persuaded, and went with the man, and learnt his art from the very beginning. When they parted, the man gave the youth a needle, and said, "With this you can sew together whatever is given you, whether it is as soft as an egg or as hard as steel; and it will all become one piece of stuff, so that no seam will be visible."
When the appointed four years were over, the four brothers arrived at the same time at the cross-roads, embraced and kissed each other, and returned home to their father. "So now," said he, quite delighted, "the wind has blown you back again to me." They told him of all that had happened to them, and that each had learnt his own trade. Now they were sitting just in front of the house under a large tree, and the father said, "I will put you all to the test, and see what you can do." Then he looked up and said to his second son, "Between two branches up at the top of this tree, there is a chaffinch's nest, tell me how many eggs there are in it?" The astronomer took his glass, looked up, and said, "There are five." Then the father said to the eldest, "Fetch the eggs down without disturbing the bird which is sitting hatching them." The skillful thief climbed up, and took the five eggs from beneath the bird, which never observed what he was doing, and remained quietly sitting where she was, and brought them down to his father. The father took them, and put one of them on each corner of the table, and the fifth in the middle, and said to the huntsman, "With one shot thou shalt shoot me the five eggs in two, through the middle." The huntsman aimed, and shot the eggs, all five as the father had desired, and that at one shot. He certainly must have had some of the powder for shooting round corners. "Now it's your turn," said the father to the fourth son; "you shall sew the eggs together again, and the young birds that are inside them as well, and you must do it so that they are not hurt by the shot." The tailor brought his needle, and sewed them as his father wished. When he had done this the thief had to climb up the tree again, and carry them to the nest, and put them back again under the bird without her being aware of it. The bird sat her full time, and after a few days the young ones crept out, and they had a red line round their necks where they had been sewn together by the tailor.
"Well," said the old man to his sons, "I begin to think you are worth more than breen clover; you have used your time well, and learnt something good. I can't say which of you deserves the most praise. That will be proved if you have but an early opportunity of using your talents." Not long after this, there was a great uproar in the country, for the King's daughter was carried off by a dragon. The King was full of trouble about it, both by day and night, and caused it to be proclaimed that whosoever brought her back should have her to wife. The four brothers said to each other, "This would be a fine opportunity for us to show what we can do!" and resolved to go forth together and liberate the King's daughter. "I will soon know where she is," said the astronomer, and looked through his telescope and said, "I see her already, she is far away from here on a rock in the sea, and the dragon is beside her watching her." Then he went to the King, and asked for a ship for himself and his brothers, and sailed with them over the sea until they came to the rock. There the King's daughter was sitting, and the dragon was lying asleep on her lap. The huntsman said, "I dare not fire, I should kill the beautiful maiden at the same time." - "Then I will try my art," said the thief, and he crept thither and stole her away from under the dragon, so quietly and dexterously, that the monster never remarked it, but went on snoring. Full of joy, they hurried off with her on board ship, and steered out into the open sea; but the dragon, who when he awoke had found no princess there, followed them, and came snorting angrily through the air. Just as he was circling above the ship, and about to descend on it, the huntsman shouldered his gun, and shot him to the heart. The monster fell down dead, but was so large and powerful that his fall shattered the whole ship. Fortunately, however, they laid hold of a couple of planks, and swam about the wide sea. Then again they were in great peril, but the tailor, who was not idle, took his wondrous needle, and with a few stitches sewed the planks together, and they seated themselves upon them, and collected together all the fragments of the vessel. Then he sewed these so skilfully together, that in a very short time the ship was once more seaworthy, and they could go home again in safety.
When the King once more saw his daughter, there were great rejoicings. He said to the four brothers, "One of you shall have her to wife, but which of you it is to be you must settle among yourselves." Then a warm contest arose among them, for each of them preferred his own claim. The astronomer said, "If I had not seen the princess, all your arts would have been useless, so she is mine." The thief said, "What would have been the use of your seeing, if I had not got her away from the dragon? so she is mine." The huntsman said, "You and the princess, and all of you, would have been torn to pieces by the dragon if my ball had not hit him, so she is mine." The tailor said, "And if I, by my art, had not sewn the ship together again, you would all of you have been miserably drowned, so she is mine." Then the King uttered this saying, "Each of you has an equal right, and as all of you cannot have the maiden, none of you shall have her, but I will give to each of you, as a reward, half a kingdom." The brothers were pleased with this decision, and said, "It is better thus than that we should be at variance with each other." Then each of them received half a kingdom, and they lived with their father in the greatest happiness as long as it pleased God.
- * * * *
Story DNA
Moral
Diverse individual skills, when combined, can overcome great challenges, but determining who deserves the most credit for a collective success can be difficult.
Plot Summary
Four poor brothers leave home to learn trades, each mastering a unique, seemingly magical skill: thievery, astronomy, hunting, and tailoring. Upon reuniting, they demonstrate their combined prowess to their father. When the King's daughter is abducted by a dragon, the brothers embark on a quest to rescue her, using their individual talents to locate, retrieve, and protect her. After their successful return, the King struggles to decide which brother deserves the princess, as all contributed equally. Ultimately, he awards each brother half a kingdom, satisfying them all.
Themes
Emotional Arc
uncertainty to triumph
Writing Style
Narrative Elements
Cultural Context
Reflects the societal value placed on craftsmanship and specialized skills in pre-industrial Europe, and the common fairy tale trope of a hero earning a princess and kingdom.
Plot Beats (15)
- A poor father sends his four sons out to learn trades, agreeing to meet in four years.
- Each brother finds a master and learns a highly specialized skill: thievery, astronomy, hunting, and tailoring.
- After four years, they reunite and return to their father.
- The father tests each son's skill: astronomer finds eggs, thief steals them from under a bird, huntsman shoots them, tailor sews them back together.
- The King's daughter is abducted by a dragon, and the King offers her hand in marriage to her rescuer.
- The brothers decide to rescue her, seeing it as an opportunity to prove their worth.
- The astronomer uses his telescope to locate the princess on a distant rock with the dragon.
- They sail to the rock, and the thief stealthily steals the princess from under the sleeping dragon.
- The dragon awakens and pursues their ship, about to attack.
- The huntsman shoots and kills the dragon, but its fall destroys their ship.
- The tailor uses his needle to sew the broken ship back together, allowing them to return safely.
- The King is overjoyed but faces a dilemma: which brother deserves the princess, as all contributed equally?
- Each brother argues for his claim to the princess.
- The King, unable to choose, declares that none will marry her, but instead awards each brother half a kingdom.
- The brothers accept the King's decision and live happily with their father.
Characters
The Father
Poor man, likely with signs of age and hardship.
Attire: Simple, worn peasant clothing appropriate for a poor man.
Wise, testing, fair, loving.
The Astronomer
No specific physical traits mentioned, but likely has keen eyesight.
Attire: Practical, perhaps slightly academic attire, suitable for a scholar or observer.
Observant, intelligent, confident, proud.
The Thief
Agile and dexterous, capable of climbing and stealth.
Attire: Dark, unassuming clothing that allows for stealth and movement.
Cunning, agile, stealthy, resourceful.
The Huntsman
Steady hands, keen eyes, strong build.
Attire: Practical hunting attire, leather, sturdy boots.
Skilled, precise, brave, confident.
The Tailor
Nimble fingers, perhaps a slightly hunched posture from his trade.
Attire: Neat, perhaps slightly formal, but practical clothing, with a thimble on his finger.
Meticulous, ingenious, patient, precise.
The King's Daughter
Beautiful maiden.
Attire: Elegant gown, perhaps slightly dishevelled from her ordeal.
Distressed, grateful, passive.
The Dragon
Large, powerful, capable of flight, with a snoring habit.
Attire: N/A (natural scales)
Terrifying, possessive, easily fooled (when asleep), vengeful.
The King
No specific description, but implied to be a figure of authority.
Attire: Royal robes, crown.
Distressed, grateful, just, wise.
Locations
Cross-way
A branching point where four different directions meet, where the brothers initially separate and later reunite.
Mood: Anticipatory, a place of new beginnings and reunions
The brothers separate to learn trades and later meet again after four years.
Father's House under a large tree
The family home, specifically the area directly in front of it, shaded by a large tree.
Mood: Familiar, domestic, a place of testing and demonstration
The father tests his sons' newly acquired skills by having them retrieve, shoot, and sew together eggs from a nest.
Rock in the Sea
A remote, isolated rock formation in the middle of the sea, where the King's daughter is held captive.
Mood: Dangerous, isolated, a place of peril and rescue
The King's daughter is discovered here with the dragon, and the thief rescues her.
The Open Sea
The vast expanse of water, initially sailed upon in a ship, then navigated on planks after the ship is destroyed.
Mood: Perilous, vast, a place of pursuit and miraculous repair
The dragon pursues the ship, is shot down, destroying the ship, and the tailor repairs the vessel from fragments.