POLITICAL PARTIES
by William Elliot Griffis · from Corea: The Hermit Nation
Adapted Version
Long ago, in Korea, many big people lived. These people were called nobles. The nobles had much power. They told the king what to do. The king's sons could not help. They stayed out of the fights.
King Sien-chong was the king then. Two nobles argued a lot. They wanted a special job. Their friends joined the fight. These friends made groups. One was "East." One was "West."
More groups started later. There was a "South" group. There was a "North" group. The "North" group argued. It split. "Big North" made a plan. The plan did not work. That group became very small. It went away.
King Suk-chong was king next. Young Yun wrote words for a stone. His Scholar's Teacher did not like them. They argued about the words. The "West" group split. It made "Old" and "New" friends. Four groups now.
These four groups were still there. People changed groups often. They wanted good jobs. They wanted jobs for their friends. They wanted their friends to be in charge. This was very big.
King Suk-chong had no son. He died. The groups chose a new king. His name was King Yeng-chong. A runner carried big news. He went away fast.
King Yeng-chong was not a kind king. People whispered bad things. They said he hurt his brother. He wanted to be king. Many people did not agree with him. He sent them far away.
King Yeng-chong had a son. His name was Prince Sato. Prince Sato wanted friends for all. But his father was very angry. The king put Prince Sato in a box. Prince Sato did not come out. This made all people very upset.
People still talked about Prince Sato. Was he good? Was he bad? This big fight made kin sad too. Kin could not agree. It was a very old fight.
Some groups wanted to hurt other groups. They sent people far away. They told lies about others. They told lies to the king. They wanted to be in charge. They wanted to be the only ones.
Kin stayed angry for a long time. They promised to get even. Some wore old clothes. This helped them know. They honored their old kin members. They wanted to make them proud.
People gave gifts. They wanted things. They made their friends rich. They made their bad ones poor. This happened again and again. New groups took their place. It was a bad cycle.
Pictures showed the groups. The Happy Noble was rich. He was very happy. Other groups were sad. The Sad Noble was poor. He wanted to get even. Some groups were stern.
The king was in charge. That was the rule. But nobles told him what to do. They were very strong. They took too much from the country. The king could not do his will.
The country needed change. The king and people must work as one. Big people needed less power. Other big countries watched Korea. New groups formed. Some wanted to change things. Some did not want change.
It was a hard time. All learned working as one is best. This was the story of the arguing groups.
Original Story
POLITICAL PARTIES.
During the past three centuries the nobles have been steadily gaining political power, or rather we might say have been regaining their ancient prestige at court. They have compelled the royal princes to take the position of absolute political neutrality, and the policy of the central government is dictated exclusively by them. Those who hold no office are often the most powerful in influence with their own party.
The origin of the political parties, which have played such an influential part in the history of modern Corea, is referred to about the time of the discovery of America. During the reign of Sien-chong (1469–1494), the eleventh sovereign of the house of Ni, a dispute broke out between two of the most powerful of the nobles. The court had bestowed upon one of them a high dignity, to which his rival laid equal claim. As usual in feudalism everywhere, the families, relatives, retainers, and even servants, of either leader took part in the quarrel. The king prudently kept himself neutral between the contending factions, which soon formed themselves into organized parties under the names of “Eastern” and “Western.” Later on, from a cause equally trivial to an alien eye, two other parties formed themselves under the names “Southern” and “Northern.” Soon the Easterners joined themselves to the Southerners, and the Northerners, who were very numerous, split into two divisions, called the Great North and the Little North. In one of those unsuccessful palace intrigues, called conspiracies, the Great North party was mixed up with the plot, and most of its members were condemned to death. The survivors hastened to range themselves under the banner of the Little North. The next reaction which arranged the parties on new lines, occurred during the reign of Suk-chong (1676–1720), and well illustrates that fanaticism of pedantry to which the literary classes in time of peace formerly devoted their energies. The father of a young noble named Yun, who belonged to the Western party, having died, the young man composed an epitaph. His tutor, an influential man of letters, not liking the production of his pupil, proposed another. Unable to agree upon the proper text, a lively controversy arose, and out of a literary acorn sprang up a mighty oak of politics. The Western party split into the Sho-ron, and No-ron, in which were found the adherents of the pupil and master. A free translation of the correlative terms sho and no, would be “Old Corea” and “Young Corea,” or Conservative and Progressive, or radical. There were now four political parties.
The Shi-seik, or “the four parties,” are still in existence, and receive illustration better from French than from British politics. Every noble in the realm is attached to one or the other of the four parties, though “trimmers” are not unknown. These Tuhil-poki, or “right and left men,” are ever on the alert for the main chance, and on the turn of the political vane promptly desert to the winning side.
However trivial the causes which led to their formation, as Western eyes see, the objects kept in view by the partisans are much the same as those of parties in European countries and in the United States. Nominally the prime purpose of each faction is to advance the interests of the country. Actual and very powerful motives have reference to the spoils of office. Each party endeavors to gain for its adherents as many of the high appointments and dignities as possible. Their rallying-point is around the heirs apparent, or possible, to the throne. When a strong and healthy king holds the reins of power, political activity may be cool. When the sovereign dies and the succession is uncertain, when a queen or royal concubine is to be chosen, when high ministers of state die or resign, the Corean political furnace is at full blast. When king Suk-chong was reigning in 1720, having no son to succeed him, the four parties coalesced into two, the Opposition and the Court or royal party. The former supported in this case one who proved the successful candidate, a brother of the king; the latter party urged the claims of an expected heir to the reigning king, which, however, was not born, as the king died childless. To secure the throne to their nominee, the brother of the childless king, the opposition secretly despatched a courier to Peking to obtain the imperial investiture. The other party sent assassins to waylay or overtake the courier, who was murdered before he had crossed the frontier.
Yeng-chong, the nominee of the Opposition, mounted the throne after the death of his brother, and reigned from 1724 to 1776. He was an able ruler, and signalized his reign by abolishing many of the legal tortures until then practised, especially the branding of criminals. Yet personally he was cruel and unscrupulous. Public rumor credited him with having found a road to power by means of a double crime. By the use of various drugs he made it impossible for his brother to have an heir, after which he poisoned him.
Stung by these reports, he began, as soon as he was made sovereign, to send to the block numbers of the opposite party whom he knew to be his enemies. Some years after, his eldest son having died, he nominated his second son, Sato, to be his heir, and associated him with himself in the government of the kingdom. This young and accomplished prince endeavored to make his father forget his bitter hatred against the Si-pai party, to proclaim general amnesty, and to follow out a frank policy of reconciliation. The king, irritated by his son’s reproaches, and hounded on by his partisans, resolved to put the prince out of the way. By the royal command a huge chest of wood was made, into which the young prince was ordered to sleep while living. The ponderous lid was put on during one of his slumbers and sealed with the royal seal. They then covered this sarcophagus with leaves and boughs, so that in a short time the young prince was smothered. This horrible crime served only to exasperate the party of the prince, and they demanded that his name should be enrolled in the list of sovereigns. Their opponents refused, and this question is still a burning one. The king’s defenders, to this day decline to rehabilitate the character of the smothered prince. The others demand that historic justice be done. Though other questions have since arisen, of more immediate moment, this particular moot point makes its distinct hue in the opposing colors of Corean politics. This, however, does not take on the features of an hereditary feud, for oftentimes in the same family, father and son, or brothers may hold varying views on this historical dispute, nor does it affect marriage between holders of diverse views. The Corean Romeo and Juliet may woo and wed without let or danger. In general, it may be said that the Piek-pai are radical and fiery, the Si-pai are conservative and conciliatory.
Cheng-chong, who ruled from 1776 to 1800, a wise, moderate, and prudent prince, and a friend of learning, favored the men of merit among the Southern Si-pai, and is also noted for having revised the code of laws.
Among the more radical of the partisans, the object in view is not only to gain for their adherents the public offices, but also to smite their rivals hip and thigh, and prevent their getting appointments. Hence the continual quarrels and the plots, which often result in the death of one or other of the leaders. Assassination and murderous attacks are among the means employed, while to supplant their enemies the king is besought to order them to death or exile. Concessions are made by the dominant party to the other only to avoid violent outbreaks, and to keep the peace. With such a rich soil for feuds, it is not wonderful that Corea is cursed with elements of permanent disturbance like those in mediæval Scotland or Italy. As each of the noble families have many retainers, and as the feuds are hereditary, the passions of human nature have full sway. All manner of envy and malice, with all uncharitableness flourish, as in a thicket of interlacing thorns. The Southern and No-ron parties have always been the most numerous, powerful, and obstinate. Between them marriages do not take place, and the noble who in an intrigue with one of his enemies loses caste, his honors, or his life, hands down to his son or his nearest relative his demand for vengeance. Often this sacred duty is associated with an exterior and visible pledge. He may give to his son, for instance, a coat which he is never to take off until revenge is had. The kinsman, thus clad with vengeance as with a garment, must wear it, it may be until he dies, and then put it upon his child with the same vow. It is not rare to see noblemen clad in rags and tatters during two or three generations. Night and day these clothes call aloud to the wearer, reminding him of the debt of blood which he must pay to appease the spirits of his ancestors.
In Corea, not to avenge one’s father is to be disowned, to prove that one is illegitimate and has no right to bear the family name, it is to violate, in its fundamental point, the national religion, which is the worship of ancestors. If the father has been put to death under the forms of law, it behooves that his enemy or his enemy’s son should die the same death. If the father has been exiled, his enemy’s exile must be secured. If the parent has been assassinated, in like manner must his enemy fall. In these cases, public sentiment applauds the avenger, as fulfilling the holy dictates of piety and religion.
The pretext of accusation most often employed by the rival factions is that of conspiracy against the life of the king. Petitions and false evidence are multiplied and bribery of the court ministers is attempted. If, as is often the case, the first petitioners are thrown in jail, beaten, or condemned to mulct or exile, the partisans assess the fine among themselves and pay it, or manage by new methods, by the favor or venality of the court ministers, or the weakness of the king, at last to compass their ends, when those of the vanquished party are ousted from office, while the victors use and abuse their positions to enrich themselves and ruin their enemies, until they in their turn are supplanted.
It is no wonder that a Corean liberal visiting in Tōkiō, in 1882, declared to a Japanese officer his conviction that Corea’s difficulties in the way of national progress were greater than those of which Japan had rid herself, mighty as these had been. By the revolutions of 1868, and later, the ripened fruits of a century of agitation and the presence of foreigners, Japan had purged from her body politic feudalism and caste, emancipating herself at once from the thrall of the priest and the soldier; but Corea, with her feudalism, her court intrigues, her Confucian bigotry, and the effete products of ages of seclusion and superstition has even a more hopeless task to attempt. The bearing of these phases of home politics will be further displayed when the new disturbing force of Christianity enters to furnish a lever to ambition and revenge, as well as to affection and philanthropy.
A native caricature, which was published about a generation ago, gives even a foreigner a fair idea of the relative position of each party at that epoch. At a table gorgeously furnished, a No-ron is seated at his ease, disposing of the bountiful fare. A Sho-ron seated beside him, yet in the rear, graciously performs the office of servant, receiving part of the food as reward for his attendance. The Little North, seeing that the viands are not for him, is also seated, but with a more sedate and serious visage. Last of all the Southern, covered with rags, keeps far in the rear, behind the No-ron, who does not notice him, while he, in vexation, grinds his teeth and shakes his fist like a man who means to take burning vengeance. Such was the political situation before 1850, as some native wit pictured it for the amusement of the Seoulians.
It requires a ruler of real ability to be equal to the pressure brought upon him by the diverse and hostile political parties. Nominally sovereign of the country, he is held in check by powerful nobles intrenched in privileges hoary with age, and backed by all the reactionary influences of feudalism. The nobles are the powerful middle term in the problem of Corean politics, who control both king and commons. The nobles have the preponderance of the government patronage, and fill the official positions with their liegemen to an extent far beyond what the theory of the law, as illustrated in the literary examinations, allows them. A native caricature thus depicts the situation. Chō-sen is represented as a human being, of whom the king is the head, the nobles the body, and the people the legs and feet. The breast and belly are full, while both head and lower limbs are gaunt and shrunken. The nobles not only drain the life-blood of the people by their rapacity, but they curtail the royal prerogative. The nation is suffering from a congestion, verging upon a dropsical condition of over-officialism.
The disease of Corea’s near neighbor, old Japan, was likewise a surplus of government and an excess of official patronage, but the body politic was purged by revolution. The obstructions between the throne and the people were cleared away by the removal of the shō-gunate and the feudal system. Before the advent of foreigners, national unity was not the absolute necessity which it became the instant that aliens fixed their dwelling on the soil. Now, the empire of the mikado rejoices in true political unity, and has subjects in a strong and not over-meddlesome government. The people are being educated in the rudiments of mutual obligations—their rights as well as their duties. The mikado himself took the oath of 1868, and his own hand shaped the august decree of 1881, which will keep his throne unshaken, not because it was won by the bows and arrows of his divine ancestors, but because it will rest broad-based upon the peoples’ will. So in Chō-sen the work of the future for intelligent patriots is the closer union of king and people, the curtailment of the power of the nobles, and the excision of feudalism. Already, to accomplish this end, there are Coreans who are ready to die. During the last decade, the pressure from Japan, the jealousy of China, the danger from Russia, the necessity, at first shrunk from and then yielded to, of making treaties with foreign nations, has altered the motives and objects of Corean politics. Old questions have fallen out of sight, and two great parties, Progressionists and Obstructionists, or Radical and Conservative, have formed for the solution of the problems thrust upon them by the nineteenth century.
Story DNA
Plot Summary
For three centuries, Korean nobles have dominated politics, forming numerous factions like 'Eastern,' 'Western,' 'Southern,' 'Northern,' 'Sho-ron,' and 'No-ron' from seemingly trivial disputes. These parties relentlessly vie for power and office, often resorting to assassination, exile, and false accusations, as exemplified by King Yeng-chong's alleged poisoning of his brother and his cruel smothering of his own son, Prince Sato, for advocating reconciliation. Deep-seated hereditary feuds, fueled by ancestor worship, perpetuate cycles of vengeance and corruption, draining the nation's resources and hindering progress. The narrative concludes by contrasting Korea's entrenched feudalism and political divisions with Japan's successful reforms, highlighting the urgent need for national unity and the curtailment of noble power in Korea.
Themes
Emotional Arc
observation of decline
Writing Style
Narrative Elements
Cultural Context
This text provides a historical overview of the formation and impact of political factions in Korea, particularly during the Joseon Dynasty, from a late 19th-century Western perspective. It highlights the deeply entrenched nature of feudal power structures and the challenges to national progress.
Plot Beats (16)
- Nobles in Korea have steadily gained political power over three centuries, controlling the central government and rendering royal princes politically neutral.
- Political parties originated during Sien-chong's reign (1469–1494) from a dispute between two nobles over a court dignity, leading to 'Eastern' and 'Western' factions.
- Other parties, 'Southern' and 'Northern,' formed later, and the 'Northerners' split into 'Great North' and 'Little North,' with the 'Great North' largely eliminated after a conspiracy.
- During Suk-chong's reign (1676–1720), a literary dispute over an epitaph caused the 'Western' party to split into 'Sho-ron' (Old Corea/Conservative) and 'No-ron' (Young Corea/Progressive), resulting in four main parties.
- These four parties, the 'Shi-seik,' still exist, with members often switching sides ('Tuhil-poki') for personal gain, and their primary goal is to secure high offices for their adherents.
- When King Suk-chong died childless in 1720, the parties coalesced into 'Opposition' and 'Court' factions, with the Opposition successfully securing the throne for the king's brother, Yeng-chong, after assassinating a courier.
- King Yeng-chong (1724–1776), a cruel ruler, abolished legal tortures but was rumored to have poisoned his brother to gain power and executed many from the opposing party.
- Yeng-chong's second son, Prince Sato, attempted to reconcile the parties but was smothered to death by royal command in a wooden chest, a crime that further inflamed party divisions.
- The question of rehabilitating Prince Sato's character remains a burning issue, illustrating the deep-seated nature of these political disputes, which can even divide families.
- Radical partisans aim not only for office but also to destroy rivals, employing assassination, exile, and false accusations of conspiracy against the king.
- Hereditary feuds are common, with families passing down vows of vengeance, sometimes symbolized by wearing rags until revenge is achieved, driven by the national religion of ancestor worship.
- Bribery and manipulation of court ministers are used to achieve political ends, leading to cycles of victors enriching themselves and ruining enemies until they are supplanted.
- A Corean liberal in 1882 recognized Korea's political difficulties as greater than Japan's, which had purged feudalism and caste through revolution.
- Native caricatures depict the No-ron party as dominant and prosperous, the Sho-ron as subservient, the Little North as serious, and the Southern party as impoverished and vengeful.
- The king is nominally sovereign but is controlled by powerful nobles who drain the nation's resources and curtail royal prerogative, leading to a 'dropsical condition of over-officialism'.
- The author concludes that Korea's future requires a closer union of king and people, curtailment of noble power, and excision of feudalism, with external pressures from Japan, China, and Russia forcing new political alignments into 'Progressionists' and 'Obstructionists'.
Characters
Sien-chong
A Korean king of the Joseon Dynasty, likely of average height and build for his era, with features typical of Korean nobility. His appearance would reflect the solemnity and authority of his position.
Attire: Royal court robes (gonryongpo) of silk, possibly in red or blue, with dragon embroidery. A black winged hat (ikseongwan) or a jeweled crown. Fine silk undergarments.
Wants: To maintain stability and his own position amidst noble disputes.
Flaw: Reluctance to intervene directly, allowing factions to solidify.
Remains largely static, observing the formation of political parties without direct intervention.
Prudent, observant, neutral.
Suk-chong
A Korean king of the Joseon Dynasty, likely of a mature age during the events described, with features typical of Korean nobility.
Attire: Royal court robes (gonryongpo) of silk, possibly in blue or green, with dragon embroidery. A black winged hat (ikseongwan) or a jeweled crown.
Wants: To secure the succession, though his actions are swayed by political parties.
Flaw: Lack of a direct heir, making him vulnerable to party manipulation.
His reign is marked by increasing party divisions and a succession crisis that he fails to resolve before his death.
Influenced by court factions, somewhat indecisive regarding succession.
Yun
A young Korean noble, likely of slender build, reflecting his scholarly pursuits rather than physical labor. His features would be refined.
Attire: Scholar's attire (dopo or durumagi) in muted colors like grey or light blue, made of fine linen or silk. A scholar's hat (gat).
Wants: To honor his deceased father with a fitting epitaph.
Flaw: His pride in his literary work, leading to conflict with his tutor.
His literary dispute with his tutor inadvertently causes a major political split within the Western party.
Intellectual, perhaps a bit stubborn in his literary convictions.
Yun's Tutor
An influential Korean man of letters, likely older and distinguished, with a scholarly appearance. Possibly of a more robust build than his pupil, reflecting his established status.
Attire: Formal scholar's attire (dopo or durumagi) in dark blue or black silk, indicating his influence. A scholar's hat (gat).
Wants: To uphold literary standards and perhaps assert his intellectual authority.
Flaw: His pedantry and unwillingness to compromise on literary matters.
His literary criticism inadvertently triggers a significant political realignment.
Influential, critical, opinionated, pedantic.
Yeng-chong
A Korean king of the Joseon Dynasty, likely of a commanding presence. His features would be sharp, reflecting his cruel and unscrupulous nature.
Attire: Royal court robes (gonryongpo) of silk, possibly in a deep red or purple, with prominent dragon embroidery. A black winged hat (ikseongwan) or a jeweled crown. His attire would be impeccably maintained, reflecting his power.
Wants: To secure and maintain his power, eliminate rivals, and avenge perceived slights.
Flaw: His cruelty and paranoia, which lead him to commit heinous acts, including against his own son.
Becomes king through ruthless means, rules effectively but cruelly, and ultimately murders his own son due to paranoia and political pressure.
Able, cruel, unscrupulous, vindictive, paranoid.
Sato
A young and accomplished Korean prince, likely of a noble and refined build. His features would be gentle and compassionate, contrasting with his father's.
Attire: Princely attire (gonryongpo or durumagi) in a lighter color like blue or green, made of fine silk, with less elaborate embroidery than the king's. A princely coronet or a scholar's hat (gat).
Wants: To reconcile political factions, bring peace to the kingdom, and soften his father's harsh rule.
Flaw: His idealism and inability to sway his father from his cruel path, leading to his downfall.
Attempts to bring about political reconciliation but is ultimately murdered by his own father due to his efforts and his father's paranoia.
Accomplished, compassionate, conciliatory, principled.
The No-ron Noble
A prosperous Korean noble, likely of a well-fed and comfortable build, reflecting his party's dominance. His features would be self-satisfied.
Attire: Luxurious silk durumagi (outer robe) in a rich color like deep green or purple, with fine embroidery. A black heukrip (horsehair hat) with a wide brim. Fine silk inner garments.
Wants: To maintain his party's political dominance and enjoy the benefits of office.
Flaw: Complacency, underestimating the resentment of other parties.
Static, representing the current state of political power.
Content, self-satisfied, dominant, enjoying the spoils of power.
The Southern Noble
A Korean noble, but one who is impoverished and marginalized, reflecting his party's low status. His build would be gaunt, and his features sharp with frustration.
Attire: Tattered and worn durumagi (outer robe) in faded, muted colors like grey or brown, made of coarse linen. His clothes would show signs of neglect and poverty.
Wants: To exact revenge on the dominant parties and regain his party's lost influence.
Flaw: His powerlessness and inability to act on his rage.
Static, representing the simmering resentment of the politically oppressed.
Vexed, angry, resentful, vengeful, marginalized.
Locations
Royal Court of Sien-chong
The inner sanctum of the Korean palace where the king presides and nobles vie for influence. Likely features vermilion lacquered columns, intricate wooden carvings, and possibly a raised dais for the monarch, reflecting Joseon dynasty architecture.
Mood: Tense, formal, politically charged, rife with intrigue and power struggles.
The initial dispute between two powerful nobles that led to the formation of the 'Eastern' and 'Western' political parties.
Palace Grounds / Gardens
The expansive outdoor areas surrounding the Korean palace, potentially featuring traditional pavilions, stone paths, and carefully manicured gardens. This is where clandestine meetings and plots might unfold, or where the 'sarcophagus' of Prince Sato was hidden.
Mood: Eerie, secretive, dangerous, a place where dark deeds are committed under the cover of night.
Prince Sato is suffocated in a wooden chest, which is then covered with leaves and boughs, a grim act of royal command.
The Frontier / Border Crossing to Peking
The desolate and dangerous boundary region between Korea and China, a critical passage for couriers carrying vital political messages. This would be a rugged, possibly mountainous or forested area, far from civilization.
Mood: Perilous, remote, tense, a place of no return for some.
A courier, secretly dispatched to Peking to secure imperial investiture for a royal nominee, is ambushed and murdered before crossing the frontier.