The Fool and The Birch-tree

by W. R. S. Ralston · from Russian Folk Tales

fairy tale trickster tale humorous Ages 8-14 1699 words 8 min read
Cover: The Fool and The Birch-tree
Original Story 1699 words · 8 min read

The Fool And The Birch-tree

THE FOOL AND THE BIRCH-TREE.[62]

In a certain country there once lived an old man who had three

sons. Two of them had their wits about them, but the third was

a fool. The old man died and his sons divided his property

among themselves by lot. The sharp-witted ones got plenty of

all sorts of good things, but nothing fell to the share of the Simpleton

but one ox--and that such a skinny one!

Well, fair-time came round, and the clever brothers got ready

to go and transact business. The Simpleton saw this, and said:

"I'll go, too, brothers, and take my ox for sale."

So he fastened a cord to the horn of the ox and drove it to

the town. On his way he happened to pass through a forest, and

in the forest there stood an old withered Birch-tree. Whenever

the wind blew the Birch-tree creaked.

"What is the Birch creaking about?" thinks the Simpleton.

"Surely it must be bargaining for my ox? Well," says he, "if

you want to buy it, why buy it. I'm not against selling it. The

price of the ox is twenty roubles. I can't take less. Out with

the money!"

The Birch made no reply, only went on creaking. But the

Simpleton fancied that it was asking for the ox on credit. "Very

good," says he, "I'll wait till to-morrow!" He tied the ox to the

Birch, took leave of the tree, and went home. Presently in came

the clever brothers, and began questioning him:

"Well, Simpleton! sold your ox?"

"I've sold it."

"For how much?"

"For twenty roubles."

"Where's the money?"

"I haven't received the money yet. It was settled I should

go for it to-morrow."

"There's simplicity for you!" say they.

Early next morning the Simpleton got up, dressed himself,

and went to the Birch-tree for his money. He reached the wood;

there stood the Birch, waving in the wind, but the ox was not to

be seen. During the night the wolves had eaten it.

"Now, then, neighbor!" he exclaimed, "pay me my money.

You promised you'd pay me to-day."

The wind blew, the Birch creaked, and the Simpleton cried:

"What a liar you are! Yesterday you kept saying, 'I'll pay

you to-morrow,' and now you make just the same promise.

Well, so be it, I'll wait one day more, but not a bit longer. I want

the money myself."

When he returned home, his brothers again questioned him

closely:

"Have you got your money?"

"No, brothers; I've got to wait for my money again."

"Whom have you sold it to?"

"To the withered Birch-tree in the forest."

"Oh, what an idiot!"

On the third day the Simpleton took his hatchet and went to

the forest. Arriving there, he demanded his money; but the

Birch-tree only creaked and creaked. "No, no, neighbor!"

says he. "If you're always going to treat me to promises,[63]

there'll be no getting anything out of you. I don't like such

joking; I'll pay you out well for it!"

With that he pitched into it with his hatchet, so that its chips

flew about in all directions. Now, in that Birch-tree there was

a hollow, and in that hollow some robbers had hidden a pot full

of gold. The tree split asunder, and the Simpleton caught sight

of the gold. He took as much of it as the skirts of his caftan

would hold, and toiled home with it. There he showed his

brothers what he had brought.

"Where did you get such a lot, Simpleton?" said they.

"A neighbor gave it me for my ox. But this isn't anything

like the whole of it; a good half of it I didn't bring home with

me! Come along, brothers, let's get the rest!"

Well, they went into the forest, secured the money, and carried

it home.

"Now mind, Simpleton," say the sensible brothers, "don't

tell anyone that we've such a lot of gold."

"Never fear, I won't tell a soul!"

All of a sudden they run up against a Diachok,[64] and says

he:--

"What's that, brothers, you're bringing from the forest?"

The sharp ones replied, "Mushrooms." But the Simpleton

contradicted them, saying:

"They're telling lies! we're carrying money; here, just take

a look at it."

The Diachok uttered such an "Oh!"--then he flung himself

on the gold, and began seizing handfuls of it and stuffing them

into his pocket. The Simpleton grew angry, dealt him a blow

with his hatchet, and struck him dead.

"Heigh, Simpleton! what have you been and done!" cried

his brothers. "You're a lost man, and you'll be the cause of our

destruction, too! Wherever shall we put the dead body?"

They thought and thought, and at last they dragged it to an

empty cellar and flung it in there. But later on in the evening

the eldest brother said to the second one:--

"This piece of work is sure to turn out badly. When they

begin looking for the Diachok, you'll see that Simpleton will tell

them everything. Let's kill a goat and bury it in the cellar, and

hide the body of the dead man in some other place."

Well, they waited till the dead of night; then they killed a

goat and flung it into the cellar, but they carried the Diachok to

another place and there hid him in the ground. Several days

passed, and then people began looking everywhere for the Diachok,

asking everyone about him.

"What do you want him for?" said the Simpleton, when he

was asked. "I killed him some time ago with my hatchet, and

my brothers carried him into the cellar."

Straightway they laid hands on the Simpleton, crying, "Take

us there and show him to us."

The Simpleton went down into the cellar, got hold of the

goat's head, and asked:--

"Was your Diachok dark-haired?"

"He was."

"And had he a beard?"

"Yes, he'd a beard."

"And horns?"

"What horns are you talking about, Simpleton?"

"Well, see for yourselves," said he, tossing up the head to

them. They looked, saw it was a goat's, spat in the Simpleton's

face, and went their ways home.

One of the most popular simpleton-tales in the world is that of the

fond parents who harrow their feelings by conjuring up the misfortunes

which may possibly await their as yet unborn grandchildren. In

Scotland it is told, in a slightly different form, of two old maids

who were once found bathed in tears, and who were obliged to confess

that they had been day-dreaming and supposing--if they had been

married, and one had had a boy and the other a girl; and if the

children, when they grew up, had married, and had had a little child;

and if it had tumbled out of the window and been killed--what a

dreadful thing it would have been. At which terrible idea they both

gave way to not unnatural tears. In one of its Russian forms, it is

told of the old parents of a boy named Lutonya, who weep over the

hypothetical death of an imaginary grandchild, thinking how sad it

would have been if a log which the old woman has dropped had killed

that as yet merely potential infant. The parent's grief appears to

Lutonya so uncalled for that he leaves home, declaring that he will

not return until he has found people more foolish than they. He

travels long and far, and witnesses several foolish doings, most of

which are familiar to us. In one place, a cow is being hoisted on to a

roof in order that it may eat the grass growing thereon; in another a

horse is being inserted into its collar by sheer force; in a third, a

woman is fetching milk from the cellar, a spoonful at a time. But the

story comes to an end before its hero has discovered the surpassing

stupidity of which he is in quest. In another Russian story of a

similar nature Lutonya goes from home in search of some one more

foolish than his mother, who has been tricked by a cunning sharper.

First he finds carpenters attempting to stretch a beam which is not

long enough, and earns their gratitude by showing them how to add a

piece to it. Then he comes to a place where sickles are unknown, and

harvesters are in the habit of biting off the ears of corn, so he

makes a sickle for them, thrusts it into a sheaf and leaves it there.

They take it for a monstrous worm, tie a cord to it, and drag it away

to the bank of the river. There they fasten one of their number to a

log and set him afloat, giving him the end of the cord, in order that

he may drag the "worm" after him into the water. The log turns over,

and the moujik with it, so that his head is under water while his legs

appear above it. "Why, brother!" they call to him from the bank, "why

are you so particular about your leggings? If they do get wet, you can

dry them at the fire." But he makes no reply, only drowns. Finally

Lutonya meets the counterpart of the well-known Irishman who, when

counting the party to which he belongs, always forgets to count

himself, and so gets into numerical difficulties. After which he

returns home.[65]

It would be easy to multiply examples of this style of humor--to

find in the folk-tales current all over Russia the equivalents of

our own facetious narratives about the wise men of Gotham, the old

woman whose petticoats were cut short by the pedlar whose name was

Stout, and a number of other inhabitants of Fool-land, to whom the

heart of childhood is still closely attached, and also of the

exaggeration-stories, the German Lügenmährchen, on which was founded

the narrative of Baron Munchausen's surprising adventures. But instead

of doing this, before passing on to the more important groups of the

Skazkas, I will quote, as this chapter's final illustrations of the

Russian story-teller's art, an "animal story" and a "legend." Here is

the former:--


Story DNA fairy tale · humorous

Moral

Sometimes, what appears to be foolishness can lead to unexpected good fortune, and perceived cleverness can lead to trouble.

Plot Summary

A foolish son inherits only a scrawny ox. Believing a creaking birch tree is bargaining, he 'sells' the ox on credit. When wolves eat the ox, he chops down the tree in anger, discovering a pot of gold. He shares this with his 'clever' brothers, but his honesty leads him to accidentally kill a man who tries to steal the gold. His brothers try to cover up the murder by replacing the body with a goat, but the fool's literal confession and presentation of the goat's head convince authorities he is mad, inadvertently saving them all from punishment.

Themes

naivety and unexpected fortunethe wisdom of foolsgreed and its consequencessocial perception vs. reality

Emotional Arc

misunderstanding to triumph to accidental trouble to accidental vindication

Writing Style

Voice: third person omniscient
Pacing: brisk
Descriptive: sparse
Techniques: repetition of dialogue structure, ironic humor

Narrative Elements

Conflict: person vs. person (brothers vs. fool, fool vs. Diachok, fool vs. society's expectations)
Ending: moral justice
the birch tree (symbol of unexpected fortune)the ox (symbol of the fool's meager inheritance)the gold (symbol of wealth and temptation)

Cultural Context

Origin: Russian
Era: timeless fairy tale

The story is presented as a 'simpleton-tale,' a common folk narrative type across many cultures, often highlighting the unexpected success of the naive or the absurdities of life.

Plot Beats (14)

  1. An old man dies, leaving two clever sons and one foolish son, who inherits only a scrawny ox.
  2. The fool decides to sell his ox at the fair, like his brothers.
  3. In the forest, the fool mistakes a creaking birch tree for a buyer, 'sells' the ox on credit, and ties it to the tree.
  4. Wolves eat the ox overnight, but the fool returns the next day, demanding payment from the tree, which continues to creak.
  5. On the third day, the fool, angered by the tree's 'broken promises,' chops it down.
  6. Inside the hollow birch, the fool discovers a pot of gold hidden by robbers.
  7. He takes some gold home, telling his brothers the 'neighbor' (the tree) paid him for the ox, and they retrieve the rest of the treasure.
  8. The brothers warn the fool not to tell anyone about the gold.
  9. The fool immediately tells a passing Diachok they are carrying money, not mushrooms, when questioned.
  10. The Diachok tries to steal gold, and the fool kills him with his hatchet.
  11. The clever brothers panic, hide the Diachok's body in a cellar, then later move it and replace it with a goat's body to protect themselves from the fool's honesty.
  12. When people search for the Diachok, the fool openly admits to killing him and says his brothers put him in the cellar.
  13. The fool leads the searchers to the cellar, pulls out a goat's head, and describes it as the Diachok, confusing the searchers.
  14. The searchers, believing the fool is insane, spit at him and leave, thus inadvertently clearing him and his brothers of the murder.

Characters 5 characters

The Simpleton ★ protagonist

human adult male

None explicitly mentioned, but implied to be a common man.

Attire: A caftan, as he uses its skirts to carry gold. Implied to be peasant attire.

A man with a hatchet, carrying a large amount of gold in his caftan.

Naive, literal-minded, easily tricked, but also unexpectedly lucky and decisive.

Image Prompt & Upload
A young man in his late teens with a naive, open-faced expression. He has messy, straw-colored hair and wide, curious blue eyes. He wears a roughspun, earthy brown tunic over patched trousers and worn leather boots. His posture is slightly hunched, with his hands clasped together in front of him, conveying a sense of humble uncertainty. Plain white background, full body visible head to toe, single figure, no watermark, no text, no signature.

The Clever Brothers ◆ supporting

human adult male

None explicitly mentioned.

Attire: Implied to be peasant attire.

Two men, often seen questioning or reacting with exasperation to their brother.

Sharp-witted, cunning, opportunistic, easily frustrated by their brother's foolishness.

Image Prompt & Upload
Two young men in their late teens, one with curly auburn hair and the other with straight black hair, both with bright, inquisitive eyes. They wear matching tailored tunics of deep green wool over white shirts and brown leather breeches. One brother holds up a intricate brass astrolabe, pointing at a gear, while the other leans in closely, a thoughtful expression on his face as he examines it. They stand side-by-side, postures alert and collaborative. Plain white background, full body visible head to toe, single figure, no watermark, no text, no signature.

The Birch-tree ○ minor

object ageless non-human

Old and withered, creaking when the wind blows, with a hollow inside.

An old, withered birch tree with a visible hollow in its trunk.

Passive, inanimate, but perceived as a bargaining entity by the Simpleton.

Image Prompt & Upload
A slender, ethereal figure with pale, smooth skin marked by faint dark horizontal lines like birch bark. Long, flowing hair the color of bright spring leaves, with a few delicate twigs and small leaves woven through it. Wearing a layered, sleeveless gown of white and grey that resembles peeled paper-bark, with a green sash at the waist. Standing gracefully with one hand resting gently on a slender, pale staff. Expression is serene and distant, with large, dark eyes. The figure is barefoot on a forest floor scattered with a few yellow leaves. Plain white background, full body visible head to toe, single figure, no watermark, no text, no signature.

The Ox ○ minor

animal adult non-human

Skinny.

Attire: A cord fastened to its horn.

A very skinny ox with a rope tied to its horn.

Docile, passive.

Image Prompt & Upload
A young, muscular humanoid figure with small curved horns protruding from his thick brown hair. He has a broad, honest face with a gentle expression, wearing a simple rough-spun tunic and trousers, barefoot. He stands in a relaxed, slightly slouched posture, holding a wooden staff. Plain white background, full body visible head to toe, single figure, no watermark, no text, no signature.

The Diachok ⚔ antagonist

human adult male

Dark-haired, with a beard (as described by the Simpleton).

Attire: None explicitly mentioned, but likely clerical or official attire given his title.

A dark-haired, bearded man stuffing handfuls of gold into his pockets.

Greedy, opportunistic, easily swayed by the sight of gold.

Image Prompt & Upload
An elderly man with a gaunt face, pale skin, and sharp, cruel features. He has deep-set, piercing black eyes and long, silver-streaked black hair that falls past his shoulders. He wears layered, dark robes of black and deep purple velvet, adorned with intricate silver embroidery depicting serpents and arcane symbols. A heavy, tarnished silver amulet hangs around his neck. He stands with an upright, rigid posture, one hand raised in a commanding gesture, fingers long and claw-like, holding a faintly glowing, malevolent-looking orb of dark energy. His expression is one of cold, calculating malice. He is in a dimly lit stone chamber, with faint green light emanating from the orb, casting sharp shadows across his face. Plain white background, full body visible head to toe, single figure, no watermark, no text, no signature.
Locations 3 locations
No image yet

Forest with a Withered Birch-tree

outdoor morning | day windy

A forest path where a withered Birch-tree stands. The tree creaks whenever the wind blows.

Mood: mysterious, slightly eerie due to the creaking tree, later becomes a place of discovery and violence

The Simpleton 'sells' his ox to the Birch-tree, later finds gold inside it, and kills the Diachok here.

withered Birch-tree forest path wind
Image Prompt & Upload
A dim, misty twilight in an ancient forest, a narrow dirt path winding between towering, shadowy oaks and pines. The atmosphere is still and hushed, with a gentle, unseen wind rustling the leaves. Centered on the path stands a stark, withered birch-tree, its bark peeled and pale like bone, branches twisted and bare against the dusky sky. The surrounding foliage is a deep, muted green and brown, with faint, ethereal beams of fading moonlight filtering through the canopy, illuminating the mist that clings to the forest floor. The scene evokes a quiet, eerie beauty, the pale tree a silent sentinel in the gloom. no border, no frame, no watermark, no text, no signature, edge-to-edge illustration
No image yet

Simpleton's Home

indoor morning | evening

The home shared by the Simpleton and his two clever brothers.

Mood: domestic, initially questioning and mocking, later surprised by the Simpleton's findings

The brothers question the Simpleton about his ox sale and later about the gold he brings home.

living quarters
Image Prompt & Upload
At dusk, a humble thatched-roof cottage sits nestled in a gentle countryside. Warm, golden light spills from its small windows, illuminating the worn wooden door and a simple vegetable garden. A winding dirt path leads to the dwelling, flanked by a gnarled apple tree and wildflowers. The sky is a soft gradient of lavender and peach, with a few early stars emerging. The atmosphere is quiet and serene, with a sense of modest, lived-in charm. no border, no frame, no watermark, no text, no signature, edge-to-edge illustration.
No image yet

Empty Cellar

indoor night implied cold/damp

A dark, empty cellar beneath the brothers' home.

Mood: secretive, grim, a place for hiding secrets

The brothers initially hide the Diachok's body here, then replace it with a goat after moving the real body.

dark cellar goat's head
Image Prompt & Upload
A subterranean stone cellar beneath an old wooden house, viewed from the foot of a narrow wooden staircase. The rough-hewn stone walls and low, arched ceiling are dark and damp, glistening with moisture in the cold air. A single, bare light bulb hanging from a frayed cord casts a weak, yellowish glow, creating deep, dramatic shadows in the corners and highlighting the texture of the stone. The floor is packed earth, swept clean and empty. The atmosphere is profoundly still, silent, and cool. No border, no frame, no watermark, no text, no signature, edge-to-edge illustration.